Snow, F. H. 1878.
On the dermal covering of a mosasauroid reptile.
Trans. Kansas Academy of Science, 6:54-58, Fig. 1-2.
Copyright © 2002-2009 by Mike Everhart
ePage created 01/17/2002; last updated 11/16/2011
LEFT: Photograph of the scales of Tylosaurus proriger (KUVP-1075)
Wherein Professor Snow describes the preserved impressions of Tylosaurus proriger scales. The specimen (KUVP-1075) is currently in the collection of the Museum of Natural History at the University of Kansas. Click HERE for a recent photograph.
TRANSACTIONS OF THE KANSAS
ON THE DERMAL COVERING 0F A MOSASAUROID REPTILE.
(Liodon dyspelor Cope.)
By Prof. F. H. SNOW, of the University of Kansas.
The geological section of the Kansas University scientific expedition for 1878, in charge of Prof. B. F. Mudge and the writer, examined with care a portion of the blue-gray shales and the yellow limestone along the Hackberry creek, in Gove County, Kansas. These rocks belong to the Niobrara group of the cretaceous formation. The locality had been previously visited by several parties of geological explorers, who had obtained from it many valuable fossils, and it was hardly expected that the gleanings from a field so thoroughly worked would contain anything of unusual value. But the frosts and rains of a single year had exposed to view many remains of fishes and saurians, and our labors were unexpectedly and abundantly rewarded . In less than three weeks, 41 saurians, 117 fishes, and 6 pterodactyls (Pteranodons) were uncovered, many of them in almost perfect condition, and of them of sufficient value to justify their transportation for a distance of 300 miles, to take their places in the cabinet of the University.
The most valuable specimen was a saurian, found in the yellow limestone by the writer. A single vertebral bone was first observed, on June 11th. upon the blue shale at the bottom of a narrow ravine. No further remains were discovered until the following day, when a systematic search was made, in company with my assistant, Mr. L. L. Dyche. We soon detected a second bone, this time one of the phalanges, lying loosely upon the side of the ravine, several feet above the first bone, and a little further up the ravine. In a few moments more the head of a vertebra was obscurely seen in the face of the solid limestone, about eight feet from the top of
ACADEMY OF SCIENCE 55
Photographed by A. G. Da Lee, Lawrence, Kansas. Drawing made by Edw. J. Nolan, Philadelphia.
DERMAL SCALES OF LIODON OWEN (TYLOSAURUS MSH.) (Natural Size)
56 TRANSACTIONS OF THE KANSAS
the ravine. An hour's work served to detach a block of rock containing several vertebrę and other bones. While removing the superfluous material from this block, in order to facilitate its removal to camp, a fortunate stroke of the hatchet revealed a peculiar reticulated surface, several square inches in extent. The thought instantly flashed upon my mind that here was something which had never before been seen by human eye. The conclusion was irresistible that the reticulated surface was the fossilized covering of the skin of the saurian, so perfectly preserved that every scale was distinctly visible, its outline clearly marked, and the elevated central line, or "carina," unmistakably indicated. Although, according to Prof. Dana's time-ratios, a period of five million years must have elapsed since this saurian swam in the shallow waters of the cretaceous seas of Western Kansas, yet each individual scale exposed to view was as perfectly preserved as if the animal had but yesterday died.
Prof. Marsh, of Yale College, some years ago described the large dermal plates, or scutes, belonging to other mosasauroid genera, which, as he writes me, "appear to be mainly confined to the neck and throat." But, so far as I am able to learn, nothing has been hitherto known of the general covering of the saurian body in any genus, and nothing whatever of the dermal covering in the genus Liodon. It might have been expected that this covering would be found to consist of larger plates, like those of the alligator and crocodile. On the contrary, it is composed of small scales, much resembling in size, shape and arrangement, the scales of living Ophidians. Dana, in his Manual of Geology (2d Edition, p. 465), speaks of the mosasaurs as "snake-like reptiles." This comparison is strengthened when it is found that their dermal scales were almost an exact pre-figuration of those of the rattlesnake, which infest the ledges within which these saurians are found. The scales first exposed to view appeared to be on the anterior portion of the ventral surface of the body, but another small area was found not far from the pelvic bones. All the scales discovered were on the lower surface of the body, the bones lying above them except in one or two spots where a bone had, by pressure, been forced through the dermal covering. The original surface exposed was afterwards increased in extent, until a total continuous area of thirty-three and one-third square inches was uncovered. This surface contains an average of ninety scales to the square inch, or a total of 3,000 scales. These are all preserved upon a single block of limestone, which also contains several vertebrę, phalanges, and other bones. A comparison with the scales of the living rattlesnake of the plains (Crotalus confluentus Say), indicates that the scales of the saurian were somewhat smaller than those of the snake, which, in a full-grown "rattler," average eighty to the square inch, instead of ninety.
On the day after the discovery of this dermal surface, I determined to obtain the remainder of the saurian, which was imbedded in the solid rock. It was necessary to remove eight feet of superincumbent material before the proper level or "horizon" , was reached, and also to undermine the specimen, in order to secure the remains in their original position, and, if possible, to expose a larger portion of the dermal covering. After three days and a half of hard labor, by myself and two assistants, we succeeded in removing one large slab, five and one-half feet by two and one-half feet, and six inches in thickness, weighing 500 lbs., and two smaller slabs, each containing the bones of a hind leg and foot. The large slab was found to contain dorsal vertebrę, ribs and pelvic bones, in perfect preservation and apparently without distortion. It also contains one of the forward limbs, or hands, lying underneath the ribs and vertebrę, with the bones in natural position.
ACADEMY OF SCIENCE. 57
In this hand there are forty-seven of the hour-glass-shaped bones of the palm and fingers, the five series consisting respectively of twelve, eleven, ten, eight, and six bones. The terminal or twelfth bone of the first series is very minute, and triangular in shape, or, more exactly, shaped like the half of an hour-glass.
No attempt has yet been made to expose the dermal covering contained in the large slab, and it is exceedingly doubtful if such an attempt would prove successful. The bones imbedded in this slab, and bow brought out in relief, are not in their natural position except, those of the hand above mentioned. Only two of the twenty vertebrę, which are scattered over the slab in all positions, remain united. The dozen ribs are variously disposed, and one of the thigh bones occupies a spot not far from the center of the lower margin of the slab. The appearance is very much as if some more powerful saurian or shark had devoured the flesh upon the larger bones of the victim, leaving untouched a portion of the skin of the lower surface of the body, and one of the front paddles, which probably did not contain much material for the gratification of his appetite.
In regard to the generic determination of this saurian, I can only say, that of the three well marked genera of the mosasauroid reptiles of the Kansas cretaceous, the specimen seems to agree most accurately with Liodon Owen (Tylosaurus Marsh). This genus is indicated by the broad neural spines, and by the fact that the number of bones in the first digit of the paddles is the greatest. The specific determination given in the title of this paper will probably be found to be correct. The specimen appears to be a small-sized individual of its species. It is possible that the species may prove to be micromus instead of dyspelor.
Front Paddle of Liodon, as drawn by W. H. Simpson
58 TRANSACTIONS OF THE KANSAS
The following measurements are appended :
In the plates which accompany this article, the dermal scales are represented of natural size, and the slab containing the bones is reduced to one-ninth its natural dimensions.
Everhart, M.J. 2005. Oceans of
Lindgren, J., Alwmark, C., Caldwell, M.W. and Fiorillo, A.R. 2009. Skin of the Cretaceous mosasaur Plotosaurus: implications for aquatic adaptations in giant marine reptiles. The Royal Society, Biological Letters, published online 8 April 2009.
Lindgren, J., Caldwell, M.W., Konishi, T. and Chiappe, L.M. 2010. Convergent evolution in aquatic tetrapods: insights from an exceptional fossil mosasaur. PLoS ONE.
Russell, D. A., 1967. Systematics and morphology of American mosasaurs. Peabody Museum of Natural History, Yale University, Bulletin 23.
Snow, F.H. 1878. On the dermal covering of a mosasauroid
Snow, F.H. 1878. On the dermal covering of a mosasauroid
Snow, F.H. 1878. On the dermal covering of a mosasauroid reptile (Liodon dyspelor Cope). Kansas City Review of Science and Industry. 2(8):451-454.
Snow, F.H. 1879. The scales of Liodon. American Naturalist 13(2):132.
Williston, S.W. 1898a. Editorial Notes. Kansas University Quarterly 7(4):235.
Williston, S.W. 1898. Mosasaurs. The University Geological